New York Association of Veterinary

May 2021

Nice staff, BEST COOKIES EVER. Better than Insomnia for sure. I literally ate 3 of the gooey warm cookies in the car as soon as we got them. Will be coming back to stock up on cookies :)

Feb 2020

WOW!!! What a great concept! I was craving cookies and went on trusty Yelp for guidance. I'm so glad I found Nocturnal Cookies! I placed a pre-order through Yelp since I placed it before their opening time of 7pm. I was set to have the cookies delivered by 8pm. They actually came just a few minutes before 8, no complaints! I ordered the 6 pack with 4 chocolate chunk, 1 peanut butter, and 1 oatmeal raisin. The chocolate chunk are amazing! Definitely not your average chocolate chip cookie. Give them a try for sure. I have to say though, the peanut butter cookie totally stole the show! I have never had a PB cookie like this one! It was warm, filled with yummy PB, and perfectly sweet! I wished I ordered more of those. The oatmeal raisin is also good, but nothing extraordinary about it tbh. All of the cookies were delivered warm, which made them taste even better imo. I paired my cookies with a pint of 2% milk, can't go wrong with that! I'm not from the area but I will definitely order again if I'm back in town!

Oct 2019

I've been hearing about this place for awhile. Last night, I felt like I'd give it a try. I'm so glad I did! I ordered online and it was delivered within 3 minutes of the projected time. The cookies arrived warm and were so delicious. The ice cream was so creamy and tasty too. The next day, I finished the cookies and they still tasted amazing! I will definitely order again.