I can't count the years I have been with Pagel, but they have always been very accommodating. Always looking for discounts, better premiums, etc. Even when I was going through some difficult times, they had me covered. Literally. I have referred countless people to Pagel. I just hope they took the great advice.
Hailey Dickie
Feb 2026
Ben Droege has been incredibly helpful in getting my car insurance set up. After experiencing some frustrations with the company directly, Ben stepped in and made the process smooth and clear. He’s thorough, transparent, and takes the time to explain everything so you feel confident in your coverage. I appreciate his professionalism and support.
Kelly Kriescher
Nov 2025
Used to be a great agency in years past, however we ended up dropping them this past month. I called multiple times for a new quote as our rate increased dramatically a couple years back. I had to call back over 3 times for an update to ultimately be told they had no luck finding a better rate. Fast forward 2 years later and no one ever reached out to search for a better rate. I ended up calling a different agency and am now saving over $2k a year on premiums and have the same amount of coverage.
Joseph
Aug 2025
I found Pagel Insurance Agency to be friendly and efficient. Kelly Pagel will put your concerns first and took care of all transactions with auto and home owner insurances. He explained all aspects of the insurance company I chose and made sure all paperwork was complete and accurate.
Justin Piontek
May 2025
Kelly was fantastic to work with! He made setting up my home insurance quick and easy. He explained everything clearly, helped me find the right coverage for my needs, and was super responsive throughout the whole process. I felt confident I was in good hands. Highly recommend Kelly if you’re looking for great service and peace of mind!
Jean Balliet
May 2025
Excellent service. Fast and friendly
Michael Couillard
Apr 2025
I wouldn't go here, been dealing with these people for 3 months about my grandfather's insurance. They have been messing around with us. They are pretty much robbing a 93 year old man. This is pathetic anything for them to make commission I would never go to this. And they told me they have me on recording agreeing to something that I didn't so I asked to hear it and the lady tells me that she doesn't have it. Again pathetic.
Amy Brown
Feb 2025
It would be nice if Justin called me back after I've already left 3 messages...in 2 weeks time
Cathy LHeureux
Jan 2025
They take very good care of their customers. Their agents are extremely helpful with answering any and all questions no matter how matter how many times they're asked
Shirley Scalish
Nov 2024
We cannot say anything but super service, great agency and a great agent named Justin L.
Brian Shelly
I can't count the years I have been with Pagel, but they have always been very accommodating. Always looking for discounts, better premiums, etc. Even when I was going through some difficult times, they had me covered. Literally. I have referred countless people to Pagel. I just hope they took the great advice.
Hailey Dickie
Ben Droege has been incredibly helpful in getting my car insurance set up. After experiencing some frustrations with the company directly, Ben stepped in and made the process smooth and clear. He’s thorough, transparent, and takes the time to explain everything so you feel confident in your coverage. I appreciate his professionalism and support.
Kelly Kriescher
Used to be a great agency in years past, however we ended up dropping them this past month. I called multiple times for a new quote as our rate increased dramatically a couple years back. I had to call back over 3 times for an update to ultimately be told they had no luck finding a better rate. Fast forward 2 years later and no one ever reached out to search for a better rate. I ended up calling a different agency and am now saving over $2k a year on premiums and have the same amount of coverage.
Joseph
I found Pagel Insurance Agency to be friendly and efficient. Kelly Pagel will put your concerns first and took care of all transactions with auto and home owner insurances. He explained all aspects of the insurance company I chose and made sure all paperwork was complete and accurate.
Justin Piontek
Kelly was fantastic to work with!
He made setting up my home insurance quick and easy. He explained everything clearly, helped me find the right coverage for my needs, and was super responsive throughout the whole process. I felt confident I was in good hands. Highly recommend Kelly if you’re looking for great service and peace of mind!
Jean Balliet
Excellent service. Fast and friendly
Michael Couillard
I wouldn't go here, been dealing with these people for 3 months about my grandfather's insurance. They have been messing around with us. They are pretty much robbing a 93 year old man. This is pathetic anything for them to make commission I would never go to this. And they told me they have me on recording agreeing to something that I didn't so I asked to hear it and the lady tells me that she doesn't have it. Again pathetic.
Amy Brown
It would be nice if Justin called me back after I've already left 3 messages...in 2 weeks time
Cathy LHeureux
They take very good care of their customers. Their agents are extremely helpful with answering any and all questions no matter how matter how many times they're asked
Shirley Scalish
We cannot say anything but super service, great agency and a great agent named Justin L.